Trinity Health-michigan: hospitals, ratings and penalties
Trinity Health-michigan is listed in Medicare records with 5% or more direct ownership and 5% or more indirect ownership in 6 hospitals in 1 state. Here is each one's star rating, Medicare penalties and size.
Non-profit Based in Livonia, MI
Average CMS star rating
3.2 of 5
Trinity Health-michigan3.2
All U.S. hospitals3.2
Across 5 rated hospitals, about the same as the U.S. average.
Patient-safety (HAC) penalty
3 hospitals
Trinity Health-michigan60%
All U.S. hospitals24%
Of 5 in the program, these have all their Medicare inpatient payments cut 1% this year for scoring in the worst quarter on hospital-acquired conditions.
Hospitals
6
In 1 state.
Beds and charity care
693 beds
$13.8 million in charity care (cost of free or discounted care) in the latest full-year Medicare cost reports.
Highest- and lowest-rated Trinity Health-michigan hospitals
By CMS overall star rating (1 to 5). Ties are broken by the patient survey rating.
Chelsea Community Hospital
Chelsea, MI · highest rated
Patients: 4 of 5 · HAC penalty
Saint Joseph Mercy Livingston Hospital
Howell, MI · highest rated
Patients: 4 of 5 · HAC penalty
Trinity Health Grand Haven Hospital
Grand Haven, MI · highest rated
Patients: 4 of 5
St Mary Mercy Hospital
Livonia, MI · lowest rated
Patients: 2 of 5 · HAC penalty
St Joseph Mercy Oakland
Pontiac, MI · lowest rated
Patients: 3 of 5
Trinity Health-michigan hospitals with the 1% Medicare penalty
Hospitals in the worst-scoring quarter nationally on hospital-acquired conditions, such as infections and surgical complications.
Every Trinity Health-michigan hospital
Click a column to sort. A dash means CMS has no rating or result for that hospital.
| Hospital | CMS stars | Patient stars | HAC penalty | ER visit | Beds |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chelsea Community HospitalChelsea, MI · Acute care | 1% cut | 3 hr 16 min | |||
| Trinity Health Grand Haven HospitalGrand Haven, MI · Acute care | No penalty | 1 hr 16 min | |||
| Saint Joseph Mercy Livingston HospitalHowell, MI · Acute care | 1% cut | 2 hr 43 min | |||
| St Mary Mercy HospitalLivonia, MI · Acute care | 1% cut | 4 hr 1 min | |||
| St Joseph Mercy OaklandPontiac, MI · Acute care | No penalty | 3 hr 20 min | |||
| Mercy Health Lakeshore CampusShelby, MI · Critical Access | – | – | 1 hr 43 min |
CMS stars: overall hospital rating, 1 to 5. Patient stars: summary of the HCAHPS patient survey. HAC penalty: a 1% cut to all Medicare inpatient payments this year for the worst-scoring quarter of hospitals on hospital-acquired conditions; critical access, children's and some other hospitals are not in the program. ER visit: typical time from arrival to leaving the emergency department. Beds: from the latest Medicare cost report.
Other non-profit hospital owners
Questions about Trinity Health-michigan
How many hospitals does Trinity Health-michigan own?
Trinity Health-michigan is listed in Medicare enrollment records with 5% or more direct ownership and 5% or more indirect ownership in 6 hospitals with a page on this site, in 1 state: Michigan (6). Records can lag behind recent sales and mergers.
How are Trinity Health-michigan hospitals rated?
The 5 hospitals with a CMS overall star rating average 3.2 of 5 stars, about the same as the U.S. average of 3.2. Highest rated: Chelsea Community Hospital (4 stars), Saint Joseph Mercy Livingston Hospital (4 stars), Trinity Health Grand Haven Hospital (4 stars). Lowest rated: St Mary Mercy Hospital (2 stars), St Joseph Mercy Oakland (2 stars).
Are any Trinity Health-michigan hospitals penalized by Medicare?
3 of its 5 hospitals in the Hospital-Acquired Condition (HAC) program (60%, vs 24% nationally) have all their Medicare inpatient payments cut 1% this year for scoring in the worst quarter on hospital-acquired conditions: Chelsea Community Hospital, Saint Joseph Mercy Livingston Hospital, St Mary Mercy Hospital.
What kind of organization is Trinity Health-michigan?
In Medicare records it is marked as non-profit, based in Livonia, MI. Owners describe themselves in these records; CMS does not verify the labels.
Does Trinity Health-michigan run these hospitals?
Trinity Health-michigan is listed as an owner or partner, not as having operational or managerial control. Organizations with 5% or more ownership, including investors in a publicly traded parent company, must be reported even if they don't run the hospital.
Hospitals list their owners in Medicare enrollment records: organizations with 5% or more ownership (direct or through other companies), partners, and organizations with operational or managerial control. A large investor can appear because it holds 5% of a publicly traded parent company, which does not mean it runs the hospitals. Records can lag behind recent sales and mergers.
Michigan Medicare penalties Michigan hospital finances Michigan non-profit hospitals All hospitals in Michigan Who owns hospitals
Medicare penalties
Source: CMS Hospital All Owners and Hospital Enrollments (data.cms.gov), CMS Care Compare and Hospital Provider Cost Reports. About the data.